48 Comments

Arjun, we really appreciated your personal note above. We couldn’t agree more.

Expand full comment
Jan 22, 2023Liked by Arjun Murti

Outstanding Arjun. Thank you very much for your informed, intelligent reporting. I will look forward to reading all of your articles. You have been very helpful to me.

Expand full comment

Love your videos with supporting data. This article's math is rebasing capex to avg demand. I suspect the 'is consistent with a 60 percent decline' is based on the same math. But isn't the 'correct' capex proportional to demand *growth* + avg decline of existing production? Maybe interesting reverse insight: What shrinkage does one have to assume to make the current capex expenditure 'midcycle'? Thanks again

Expand full comment
Dec 13, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

I love Super-Spiked! The best analysis out there today.

Question: does it make sense to say that the CAPEX deficit is well known, virtually everyone knows that capital is being constrained to the O&G industry, but few people are concerned about it because the general consensus is that it isn't a problem because global demand will peak soon based on the IEA/EIA's demand projections? And that the surprise, the 'aha' trigger moment, comes when the reality of sustained high global demand finally sinks?

Expand full comment
Dec 5, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Fantastic analysis as usual! Amazing how often figures are presented without normalizing for inflation! Exhibit 3 is even more revealing, and I think the separation between the last cycle and the current one is even larger - since normalizing just by future demand does not factor into consideration the higher “Maintenance Capex” needed at the higher output levels today. In other words, even in a flat demand world, the capex needed today is higher vs the capex needed 20 years ago just to keep production flat at the higher output levels (from a geeky viewpoint, the relation is not Y=mX which you can normalize by division, but a Y = mX + c relationship 😊).

Expand full comment

To begin, many, many thanks for the fabulous information that you provide. I have only been an active investor in the energy sector since the beginning of 2021. Prior to that I was essentially a passive investor buying index funds; a better understanding of the cyclical nature of the energy sector is thus of paramount importance. There are two issues that I would like to submit to you; the first one deals with the approach I have used thus far for my oil and gas investments while the second one deals with the electricity sector in which I have (think at least) relevant knowledge and expertise. (1) The first issue, on which I would appreciate your comments, is that, up to now, I have only invested in Canadian companies, not for patriotic reason (but yes I’m Canadian) but because of the oil sands: I figure that with the third largest oil reserves in the world and low depletion rates, little if any exploration is required which seems to me very positive in terms of the cyclical pitfalls that you so aptly describe. In addition Imperial Oil (69.6% owned by Exxon/Mobil) seems to agree with me; upon selling their conventional oil assets in Canada, their August 31, 2022 press release states the following: “The sale is consistent with Imperial’s strategy to focus upstream resources on key oil sands assets and its commitment to deliver long-term value to shareholders.” Should some of your readers be interested in the Canadian energy sector they could start by looking at XEG, the iShare Canada ETF (traded in $CAD on the TSX) provided by the Blackrock group; in that ETF the 5 largest companies (72.4% of total assets) can also be traded on US markets in $USD (4 on the NYSE and 1 on the OTC). (2) I will conclude this post with brief remarks on the role of wind and solar in the electricity sector; this role should be gross zero percent because both feature 2 terminal diseases. The fact that they have the bad habit of not producing when needed is the first obvious reason but the second reason is the worst offender; it is the reverse situation when, during low demand periods, they start producing large quantities of kWh. In such occasions wind and solar systematically destroy the economics of base stations. The inevitable result of these two terminal diseases is thus stratospheric electricity rates on one hand and a tremendous loss of reliability on the other. Regards and I can’t wait until next Saturday.

Expand full comment

Excellent framework for determining where we are at in the cycle. The one thing that would be helpful to understand along with the capital spend is the capital intensity of bringing the marginal barrel to market and how this compares to the last cycle. I suspect that depletion of more easily recoverable resources has led to more expensive marginal barrels (shale, ultra deep water, etc), which has been at least partially been offset by advances in technology, productivity and scale. Any sense of how much capex is needed for today's marginal barrel vs last cycle?

Expand full comment
Dec 4, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Great article. However, I didn't see oil demand get mentioned. When comparing to the previous boom/bust period from a decade ago, oil demand was projected to grow for the foreseeable future. Currently though, it's not as sure of a bet that oil demand will continue to increase as it did in the past due to converting to cleaner and more renewable energy sources.

I was thinking that chart that compared CAPEX between our current period and the previous oil boom, could that be added, adjusted, or correlated to paint a clearer picture? (Who knows though, maybe future oil demand for the next 10 years is close to the same as the prvious 10 years.) Thanks!

Expand full comment

Very nice analysis! Thanks for posting. All topics I spend a lot of time thinking about and I appreciate the clarity of your thinking. In my own work I analyze various oil companies on a quarterly basis, and its obvious they are underinvesting to maintain future energy supply. It makes for good short term results, but we are headed for a production cliff that the world just isn't ready to deal with. Again, thanks for a great post. Glad to be here. Cheers

Expand full comment
Dec 4, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Damn great piece Arjun...such a helpful framing and what a great way to put your years of energy experience to work for the public good

Expand full comment
Dec 4, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Great breakdown and supporting graphs! One factor keeps nagging me r/e the next bull cycle relates to the availability of adequate accretive projects to actually invest in. What are your thoughts around the runway left in US unconventional inventory and whether there’s enough left in the tank to underwrite another run? I’m curious if we could see US unconventional ROCE degradation in lockstep with well productivity declines (as we transition from higher tier to good but not as great acreage), even in higher price environment. Oil could still have a sustained bull run but the balance between US and the rest of the world could dramatically shift. Thoughts?

Expand full comment
Dec 3, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

I would argue that these voices are not just anti-capitalism and pro-socialism, but in many cases anti-human. I was just watching an interview with renowned CPU architect Jim Keller by Jordan Peterson on the subject of the future of AI and Jim pointed out two things: 1. His children are basically being taught in university that humans are a virus on the planet and 2. he's an optimist that shares Elon Musk's view that we actually don't have enough people and we need more. I was trying to communicate to my own daughter this idea that the anti-human view is generally held by politicians and academics of little practical accomplishment, the optimist pro-human view is held by some of the worlds most prominent and practically accomplished intellects.

Expand full comment
Dec 3, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Excellent writeup !! Thanks 😊🌈

Expand full comment
Dec 3, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Karnes, Atascosa, and Live Oak.

Expand full comment
Dec 3, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

Hi Arjun,

Thanks again for another excellent weekly column. I started to invest in energy in March 2020. I have made a lot of mistakes and some gains too. I have learned from a lot people. But your weekly columns and videos, which I discovered in Spring of this year, have been the most beneficial ones to me (and are free too). Thanks again! I am looking forward to hearing your space with George Noble on Monday.

Expand full comment
Dec 3, 2022Liked by Arjun Murti

That was a great analysis, definitely worth the read. Is there a publication that digs deep into oil and gas companies and recommends potential investments in these companies?

Expand full comment